Homes for Sale in Rye City, NY – Jeremy Zucker Real Estate

Advanced Search Market Reports Home Value Connect

Discover an exquisite selection of homes for sale in Rye City, NY, a coveted waterfront community offering unparalleled lifestyle and convenience. Prospective buyers will find diverse real estate options, from historic colonial estates near the Rye Golf Club to modern residences in Milton Point with breathtaking Long Island Sound views. This charming Westchester County city is renowned for its excellent schools, vibrant downtown, and proximity to scenic parks like Playland Park, making it an ideal destination for families and professionals seeking a refined suburban experience. Explore the latest listings and find your perfect home in Rye's dynamic market.

Search Rye City, NY by Lifestyle

Search Rye City, NY by Price

Search Rye City, NY by Bedrooms

Search Rye City, NY by Bathrooms

Exploring Homes for Sale Across Rye City Neighborhoods

Greenhaven: Waterfront and Executive Homes

Greenhaven offers some of the most sought-after homes for sale, characterized by luxurious waterfront properties and expansive executive residences. Residents enjoy private beach clubs and stunning views, making it a prime location for those desiring an exclusive coastal lifestyle in Rye City, NY.

Milton Point: Coastal Charm and Historic Estates

Milton Point showcases a unique blend of coastal charm and historic estates among its homes for sale. From elegant Victorians to sophisticated contemporary designs, properties here often feature deep water access and proximity to the American Yacht Club, embodying Rye's rich maritime heritage.

Rye Beach: Family-Friendly Living and Accessibility

For families seeking homes for sale with easy access to amenities, Rye Beach provides an attractive option. This area is known for its tree-lined streets, spacious properties, and close proximity to Rye Town Park and the tranquil shores of Oakland Beach, offering a balanced lifestyle for all ages.

Diverse Home Types and Architectural Styles in Rye

Historic Homes and Timeless Estates

The collection of homes for sale in Rye City, NY, frequently includes magnificent historic properties. These estates often feature classic Colonial, Tudor, and Victorian architecture, meticulously preserved and updated to blend historical grandeur with modern comforts. Many are situated on generous plots with mature landscaping.

Modern Residences and New Constructions

Beyond its historic charm, Rye City also presents opportunities for those seeking contemporary homes for sale. A growing number of modern residences and newly constructed properties offer open floor plans, state-of-the-art amenities, and energy-efficient designs, catering to a sophisticated, modern aesthetic.

Waterfront Properties and Views

One of the most defining characteristics of homes for sale in Rye City is the availability of stunning waterfront properties. Whether on the Long Island Sound or one of Rye's picturesque harbors, these homes provide unparalleled vistas and direct access to marine activities, representing the pinnacle of luxury living.

The Rye City Lifestyle: Beyond Homes for Sale

Top-Tier Education and Family Amenities

Rye City, NY, is renowned for its exceptional public and private schools, making the search for homes for sale here particularly appealing to families. Beyond academics, the community offers numerous parks, recreational programs, and safe environments for children to thrive, including access to the Rye Nature Center.

Vibrant Downtown and Cultural Attractions

The vibrant downtown area of Rye City is a significant draw for residents. Homes for sale in close proximity benefit from easy access to upscale boutiques, diverse dining options, and cultural venues like the Rye Arts Center. The pedestrian-friendly streets create a welcoming atmosphere for shopping and socializing.

Commuting and Accessibility

Despite its serene suburban feel, Rye City offers excellent connectivity. Homes for sale here are a short walk or drive from the Metro North station, providing a convenient commute to Grand Central Terminal in New York City. Major parkways also ensure easy access to surrounding Westchester County and Connecticut destinations.

Newest Homes for Sale in Rye City, NY

$335,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1047961 MLS

Welcome to Blind Brook Lodge, a charming Tudor-style apartment community ideally located in the heart of Rye. This inviting one-bedroom residence offers a wonderful combination of comfort, character, and convenience. Enjoy the best of Rye just outside your door, with shops, restaurants, the train station, parks, and all that downtown has to offer just moments away. Enjoy private parking and the gardens that you could have your own vegetable or flower garden. Set within a beautifully maintained community with classic Tudor-inspired architecture, this is a fantastic opportunity to enjoy a convenient in-town lifestyle in one of Rye’s most desirable locations.

66 Milton Road Unit #G42, Rye

$6,995,000

7 Beds ⋅ 9 Baths ⋅ 1048484 MLS

Set high on 2.08 serene, private acres within the prestigious Westchester Country Club grounds (Rye PO / Harrison), this reimagined stone manor blends modern turnkey luxury with timeless architectural pedigree. Spanning 9,300+ SF of pristine, light-filled living space, the residence is curated for effortless everyday living and entertaining. The heart of the home is a culinary chef’s kitchen featuring a Carrara marble island, top-tier appliances, dual dishwashers, and a butler’s pantry, opening directly to an expansive coffered-ceiling family room with outdoor access to sizable deck and expansive grounds. Work from home in a quiet executive office or unwind in formal living room, framed by original leaded-glass doors and hand-hewn millwork. Upstairs, the vaulted primary retreat boasts custom closets, a spa bath with steam shower and radiant heat, a gas fireplace, and a private, screened sleeping porch capturing open views of the lush grounds. Designed for active wellness and recreation, the radiant-heated walkout lower level features a custom sauna, full bath, second laundry and flexible area ideal for lounge and fitness. For the automotive and sports enthusiast, an iconic porte-cochere leads to an extraordinary 4-car garage setup, in conjunction with a climate-controlled 3-car auxiliary garage. Complete with Marvin windows, energy-efficient systems, and elevator-ready access across all levels. An unmatched lifestyle location: tucked away in privacy, yet minutes to top-ranked public and private schools, downtown dining, golf, major highways, and a 40-minute commute to Manhattan. Move-in ready perfection.

4 Commodore Avenue, Rye

$4,595,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1048123 MLS

Spectacular transitional home, custom built in 2023 with the highest level of craftsmanship and attention to detail by esteemed local developer, Landmark Construction. Sun filled rooms with 20 foot vaulted ceilings and a continuous wall of glass provides a stunning view of the idyllic landscape. The open floor plan features a gorgeous 10 foot island that bridges the living room with gas fireplace and the dining area and includes a state of the art sound system making it perfect for entertaining. Outdoors is a covered heated kitchen with entertainment system, leading to an extensive bluestone patio with an outdoor wood-burning fireplace and salt water hot tub. The main floor includes a bedroom with en suite bath and an office. Upstairs is a primary suite, with spa bath and 2 WICs, a bedroom with en suite bath, 2 bedrooms, hall bath and laundry. The lower level with high ceilings, expansive recreation area with multi media walls, custom bar, gym, bedroom and full bath complete this dream home.

9 Kirby Lane N, Rye

$2,395,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1032343 MLS

Perfectly positioned in Rye's sought-after Milton Point neighborhood, 23 Fairlawn Street offers the rare combination of turnkey living, exceptional outdoor space, and an unbeatable location just moments from Rye Town Park and Beach, Rye Marina, and Milton School. Thoughtfully gut renovated in 2016/2017, this four-bedroom, two full and one half bath Colonial blends timeless design with modern functionality, creating a home that is truly move-in ready. At the heart of the home is a beautifully designed eat-in kitchen featuring a large center island, high end appliances, abundant storage, and custom soft-close cabinetry. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and living rooms, as well as the family room, where sliding glass doors open to an expansive Trex deck overlooking the impressive fully fenced backyard—an ideal setting for outdoor entertaining, play, or simply enjoying the privacy of your own retreat. A convenient rear gate provides direct access to the pathway leading to Milton School. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite is a true sanctuary, complete with vaulted ceilings, a generous walk-in closet, and a beautifully appointed ensuite bath. Three additional bedrooms, a renovated hall bath, and the convenience of a second-floor laundry room complete the upper level. Offering the perfect balance of style, comfort, and location, 23 Fairlawn Street presents an exceptional opportunity to enjoy all that Rye's coveted Milton Point neighborhood has to offer.

23 Fairlawn Street, Rye

$2,795,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1043675 MLS

Spacious Ranch with Exceptional Potential in Prime Rye City Location Located on a desirable cul-de-sac in a sought-after Rye City neighborhood, this spacious ranch offers a combination of location, generous living space, and tremendous potential. Just minutes from Midland School, Rye Recreation, shopping, and local amenities, the property is ideally positioned for both everyday living and long-term value. The main level features generously sized rooms, an updated kitchen, and hardwood floors throughout. The finished walk-out lower level significantly expands the usable living space and includes a large playroom with fireplace and sliding doors leading directly to the backyard, a bedroom with ensuite bathroom, gym, laundry, and additional unfinished storage. The property sits on lovely grounds with a fenced-in underground pool, creating excellent outdoor living and entertaining space. The layout and lot also offer an opportunity to explore future expansion or reconfiguration, subject to zoning and municipal approvals. Depending on the buyer's needs, there may be potential to enlarge the existing footprint, add additional living space, rework the current layout, or further enhance the lower level. This makes the property an excellent opportunity for a buyer looking for a home that can be enjoyed as-is while also offering the potential to create a larger, more customized residence over time. A rare opportunity to purchase a well-located Rye City ranch with substantial existing space, desirable outdoor amenities, and significant potential for future improvements and expansion. Also offered for Rent $10,500 per month.

3 Lea Place, Rye

$2,975,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 893842 MLS

Step off your private elevator into this newly constructed luxury condominium situated steps from downtown Rye's fabulous restaurants and shops. Built with the highest level of craftsmanship and attention to detail by esteemed local developer Landmark Construction, this gorgeous home with sun filled rooms and vaulted ceilings is what you've been waiting for. Off your foyer is an open floor plan featuring a custom JWH kitchen and bar area with Sub Zero and Wolf Appliances that flows seamlessly into your living area with gas fireplace and dining area with sliders to a balcony. Down the hallway are 2 bedrooms each with sliders to a private balcony and en-suite bathroom with radiant heated floor. The primary suite includes 2 WICs, a spa bath with soaking tub and radiant heat floor, and a primary bedroom with sliders onto a balcony where you can sit back and relax looking at the beautifully landscaped back yard.

54 Locust Avenue Unit #A, Rye

$1,350,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1039957 MLS

Welcome to 14 Fernwood Avenue, a charming Tudor-style home ideally situated on one of Rye's quiet,treelined residential streets. This inviting 3+ bedroo, 2 bath home offers a wonderful blend of classic character and comfortable living. The spacious updated eat-in kitchen provides a warm and welcoming gathering space, while a fireplace adds character and ambiance to the homes living spaces. Outside, enjoy a private, fenced yard with patio perfect for outdoor dining, play, gardening, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Mature trees and the tranquil settiing of Fernwood Avenuecreate a wonderful sense of privacy while keeping you close to everything Rye has to offer. The location is exceptional; just 1/2 mile to the beach, one mile from downtown Rye, and a short stroll to Rye Middle and Rye High Schools, Enjoy easy access to Rye's shops, restaurants, schools, parks and waterfront while coming home to a quiet beautifully established neighborhood.

14 Fernwood Avenue, Rye

$549,500

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1036914 MLS

This pristine condo offers the perfect combination of comfort and convenience, just a short stroll to the train and village! Freshly painted, refinished wood flooring renovated kitchen and bath, updated recessed lighting , central air conditioning, stainless steel appliances, cherrywood cabinetry, and a private storage room. Parking is a bonus with one detached garage space plus one outdoor parking space included in monthly maintenance Ideally located close to shopping, YMCA, Rye Historical Society, Rye Art Center and Rye's fabulous restaurants.....enjoy nearby golf, boating, beach, award-winning schools, parks, and more. With the train station just minutes away, this truly is an easy commuter’s delight! ** MM = $645 per Month Pets allowed Washer and Dryer Installation option exists

184 Purchase Street Unit #1-1, Rye

$1,500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1033533 MLS

Well maintained 3 unit building in the heart of downtown Rye with 2 driveway parking spots. Walking distance to Metro North, Shops & Restaurants, Rye Middle & High Schools, Rye Library, Rye YMCA. 1st Floor Unit 1 BR 1 Bath, 2nd Floor Unit 1 BR 1 Bath, 3rd Floor Unit 2 BR 1 Bath. Current tenants are renting month to month below the fair market rate. Updates: New Gutters 2021, New Front Porch Roof 2021, Front Porch New Posts. Railings & Floor 2016, New Building Roof 2016, Replaced Siding & Windows 2005.

1095 Boston Post Road, Rye

$4,400,000

8 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 1031136 MLS

A truly rare opportunity in Rye. Set on nearly 5 spectacular, estate-like acres in the Rye City School District, this is one of those properties that simply cannot be replicated today. The breathtaking grounds create a private retreat complete with an in-ground pool, expansive lawns, mature landscaping, and endless space to entertain, relax, or play. At the heart of the outdoor experience is an exceptional pool house that lives like a true second home—a pristine, newer residence featuring approximately 1,600+ square feet, three bedrooms, three full baths, a beautiful modern kitchen, spacious living area with fireplace, and covered patio overlooking the pool. Whether used for extended family, guests, an au pair, home office, or multigenerational living, it is a remarkable amenity rarely found at this level. The stately Colonial offers nearly 5,000 square feet with an outstanding floor plan, generous room sizes, sun-filled living spaces, a grand foyer, formal living and dining rooms, private office, spacious family room with stone fireplace and wet bar, sunroom, and five bedrooms including a gracious primary suite. The home has been meticulously maintained and presents the perfect opportunity to update and customize to your own style while preserving its exceptional layout and timeless character. An added bonus—and a major value enhancement—is the property's new connection to public sewer, eliminating one of the biggest concerns associated with estate properties while providing long-term peace of mind. Just minutes from downtown Rye, beaches, parks, marinas, restaurants, Metro-North, and award-winning Rye City Schools, this is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to own an estate-sized property with a true second residence in one of Westchester's most sought-after communities. Properties offering this combination of acreage, privacy, flexibility, and location are extraordinarily rare.

415 Grace Church Street, Rye

$3,499,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1036005 MLS

Nestled in the heart of Rye's coveted Greenhaven waterfront community, with DEEDED RIGHTS TO THE PRIVATE BEACH AND PIER located just steps away - at the end of the street, minutes from Greenwich, this exceptional 5-bedroom, 5.1 bathroom residence offers an extraordinary opportunity to enjoy luxury living in one of Westchester County's most prestigious neighborhoods. Situated on an expansive half acre lot, this lovingly maintained home boasts 3,804 square feet of beautifully designed living space, which does not include the lower level offering an additional 1300 sq ft of endless potential possibilities for recreation, a home gym, media room, guest quarters, or multigenerational living. Built in 1988, the home showcases a timeless brick colonial design with spacious, light-filled rooms, gracious entertaining spaces, and a seamless flow ideal for both everyday living and elegant gatherings. The generous floor plan offers oversized bedrooms, multiple living and entertaining areas with fireplaces. Outside, the level landscaped grounds create a private retreat with plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, or the addition of a pool. Set on over half an acre in the sought-after Greenhaven neighborhood, you'll enjoy a serene residential setting and moments from Milton Harbor, marinas, parks, beaches, and scenic waterfront walks. Residents appreciate Greenhaven's unique waterfront lifestyle while remaining just minutes from downtown Rye's vibrant restaurants, boutique shopping, Metro-North station, award-winning schools, and major highways, providing an effortless commute to Manhattan. House has been updated with new forced air heating system/central air and new H/W heater.

90 Greenhaven Road, Rye

$4,795,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1024563 MLS

Introducing an iconic Milton Point treasure that best combines true architectural mastery alongside a coveted waterfront location. This stunning Victorian has been fully renovated, expanded and thoughtfully improved, inside and out, sparing no expense to preserve and enhance the historic details now blended perfectly with all imaginable modern amenities. An unreplicable home in a premier Rye location, offering partial water views and shared deep water dock. A rare find not to be missed.

731 Forest Avenue, Rye

Start Your Search

Prev
1
2
3
of 3
Next

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.