Explore Homes for Sale in Rye City, NY
Map Search for Rye City, NY Homes for Sale

Homes for Sale in Rye City, NY – Jeremy Zucker Real Estate

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Discover an exquisite selection of homes for sale in Rye City, NY, a coveted waterfront community offering unparalleled lifestyle and convenience. Prospective buyers will find diverse real estate options, from historic colonial estates near the Rye Golf Club to modern residences in Milton Point with breathtaking Long Island Sound views. This charming Westchester County city is renowned for its excellent schools, vibrant downtown, and proximity to scenic parks like Playland Park, making it an ideal destination for families and professionals seeking a refined suburban experience. Explore the latest listings and find your perfect home in Rye's dynamic market.

Search Rye City, NY by Lifestyle
Search Rye City, NY by Price
Search Rye City, NY by Bedrooms
Search Rye City, NY by Bathrooms

Exploring Homes for Sale Across Rye City Neighborhoods

Greenhaven: Waterfront and Executive Homes

Greenhaven offers some of the most sought-after homes for sale, characterized by luxurious waterfront properties and expansive executive residences. Residents enjoy private beach clubs and stunning views, making it a prime location for those desiring an exclusive coastal lifestyle in Rye City, NY.

Milton Point: Coastal Charm and Historic Estates

Milton Point showcases a unique blend of coastal charm and historic estates among its homes for sale. From elegant Victorians to sophisticated contemporary designs, properties here often feature deep water access and proximity to the American Yacht Club, embodying Rye's rich maritime heritage.

Rye Beach: Family-Friendly Living and Accessibility

For families seeking homes for sale with easy access to amenities, Rye Beach provides an attractive option. This area is known for its tree-lined streets, spacious properties, and close proximity to Rye Town Park and the tranquil shores of Oakland Beach, offering a balanced lifestyle for all ages.

Diverse Home Types and Architectural Styles in Rye

Historic Homes and Timeless Estates

The collection of homes for sale in Rye City, NY, frequently includes magnificent historic properties. These estates often feature classic Colonial, Tudor, and Victorian architecture, meticulously preserved and updated to blend historical grandeur with modern comforts. Many are situated on generous plots with mature landscaping.

Modern Residences and New Constructions

Beyond its historic charm, Rye City also presents opportunities for those seeking contemporary homes for sale. A growing number of modern residences and newly constructed properties offer open floor plans, state-of-the-art amenities, and energy-efficient designs, catering to a sophisticated, modern aesthetic.

Waterfront Properties and Views

One of the most defining characteristics of homes for sale in Rye City is the availability of stunning waterfront properties. Whether on the Long Island Sound or one of Rye's picturesque harbors, these homes provide unparalleled vistas and direct access to marine activities, representing the pinnacle of luxury living.

The Rye City Lifestyle: Beyond Homes for Sale

Top-Tier Education and Family Amenities

Rye City, NY, is renowned for its exceptional public and private schools, making the search for homes for sale here particularly appealing to families. Beyond academics, the community offers numerous parks, recreational programs, and safe environments for children to thrive, including access to the Rye Nature Center.

Vibrant Downtown and Cultural Attractions

The vibrant downtown area of Rye City is a significant draw for residents. Homes for sale in close proximity benefit from easy access to upscale boutiques, diverse dining options, and cultural venues like the Rye Arts Center. The pedestrian-friendly streets create a welcoming atmosphere for shopping and socializing.

Commuting and Accessibility

Despite its serene suburban feel, Rye City offers excellent connectivity. Homes for sale here are a short walk or drive from the Metro North station, providing a convenient commute to Grand Central Terminal in New York City. Major parkways also ensure easy access to surrounding Westchester County and Connecticut destinations.

Newest Homes for Sale in Rye City, NY

$3,499,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1036005 MLS
Nestled in the heart of Rye's coveted Greenhaven waterfront community, with DEEDED RIGHTS TO THE PRIVATE BEACH AND PIER located just steps away - at the end of the street, minutes from Greenwich, this exceptional 5-bedroom, 5.1 bathroom residence offers an extraordinary opportunity to enjoy luxury living in one of Westchester County's most prestigious neighborhoods. Situated on an expansive half acre lot, this lovingly maintained home boasts 3,804 square feet of beautifully designed living space, which does not include the lower level offering an additional 1300 sq ft of endless potential possibilities for recreation, a home gym, media room, guest quarters, or multigenerational living. Built in 1988, the home showcases a timeless brick colonial design with spacious, light-filled rooms, gracious entertaining spaces, and a seamless flow ideal for both everyday living and elegant gatherings. The generous floor plan offers oversized bedrooms, multiple living and entertaining areas with fireplaces. Outside, the level landscaped grounds create a private retreat with plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, or the addition of a pool. Set on over half an acre in the sought-after Greenhaven neighborhood, you'll enjoy a serene residential setting and moments from Milton Harbor, marinas, parks, beaches, and scenic waterfront walks. Residents appreciate Greenhaven's unique waterfront lifestyle while remaining just minutes from downtown Rye's vibrant restaurants, boutique shopping, Metro-North station, award-winning schools, and major highways, providing an effortless commute to Manhattan. House has been updated with new forced air heating system/central air and new H/W heater.

90 Greenhaven Road, Rye
$4,795,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1024563 MLS
Introducing an iconic Milton Point treasure that best combines true architectural mastery alongside a coveted waterfront location. This stunning Victorian has been fully renovated, expanded and thoughtfully improved, inside and out, sparing no expense to preserve and enhance the historic details now blended perfectly with all imaginable modern amenities. An unreplicable home in a premier Rye location, offering partial water views and shared deep water dock. A rare find not to be missed.

731 Forest Avenue, Rye
$3,095,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1022311 MLS
Public Remarks Experience unparalleled luxury at The St. Regis Residences, Rye, an exclusive 55+ condominium community offering legendary St. Regis service and world-class amenities. This rare three-bedroom, three-bath patio residence features a gracious open floor plan with seamless indoor-outdoor living and direct access to a private patio. Elegant finishes include contemporary Italian kitchen and bath cabinetry, stone and quartz countertops, a spa-inspired primary bath with heated floors, Kohler fixtures, a gas fireplace, hardwood and stone tile flooring, oversized windows, Sub-Zero, Wolf, and Bosch appliances, a wine refrigerator, spacious walk-in closet, and a private butler's closet. Residents enjoy exceptional amenities including full-service staff, three club rooms, an indoor pool, fitness center, screening room, golf simulator, and beautifully landscaped grounds with walking paths, water features, outdoor fire pits, and flowering gardens. Experience the ultimate in luxury, comfort, and convenience in one of Rye's most prestigious residential communities.

120 Old Post Road Unit #C107, Rye
$299,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1019326 MLS
Welcome to Blind Brook Lodge. Stately pre-war brick Tudor-style building in the heart of Rye! Here timeless architecture, character and a park-like setting come together. This updated one-bedroom residence offers the rare advantage of its own private entrance, providing added privacy. Features new flooring, updated galley kitchen, and dining area, large living room, spacious bedroom and ample closet space throughout. Interior freshly painted throughout. This unit boasts high ceilings that create a bright, open ambience. The floor plan offers comfortable living with an effortless flow. Expansive grounds feature beautiful gardens, playground and outdoor seating areas. Blind Brook Lodge has a new building generator, elevators, common laundry, assigned parking and onsite storage. Close to town, shops, restaurants, library, Rye Arts Center, Rye Recreation, Rye YMCA, park, beach, highways and Metro North Train station. Whether you are purchasing your first home, downsizing, or seeking a low maintenance lifestyle, this residence presents an outstanding opportunity in one of Rye's most desirable communities.

66 Milton Road Unit #A1, Rye
$7,995,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1015115 MLS
Tucked away at the end of a long private drive, hidden from view and unknown to many who pass nearby, this extraordinary waterfront estate offers a rare combination of privacy, history, and lifestyle in one of Rye’s most coveted neighborhoods. Originally built in 1856 as part of the area’s original homestead and thoughtfully expanded and enhanced over the years, the property spans 1.59 spectacular acres along Milton Harbor with direct access to Long Island Sound. A world apart from the ordinary, the 5,233-square-foot residence is surrounded by breathtaking gardens, mature specimen plantings, and a series of enchanting outdoor spaces that unfold from one destination to the next. Multiple terraces invite al fresco dining and entertaining—from morning coffee overlooking the water, to sunset cocktails by the pool, to gatherings at the dock as boats return from a day on the Sound. With six bedrooms, five full and one half baths, four garage bays, a waterside pool, and a private dock accommodating a vessel up to approximately 32 feet, the property delivers an unrivaled waterfront lifestyle. The setting evokes a distinctive “Bedford meets the water” feel—an uncommon blend of estate-like grounds, privacy, and natural beauty rarely found on the shoreline. While the home enjoys all the benefits of the vibrant Hix Park neighborhood community, it lives as its own private sanctuary. This is not a cookie-cutter property. It is for the buyer seeking something truly unique: a place with history, character, extraordinary land, stunning gardens, a dock, pool, water access, and a sense of discovery that cannot be replicated.

87 Hix Avenue, Rye
$185,000
1 Baths ⋅ 1014135 MLS
Fully renovated, cheerful studio just 2 blocks to Metro North and all that Rye has to offer. A spacious kitchen features an eating/working island open to living area. Washer and dryer in unit. Assigned parking spot on site. Beach rights. Perfect for easy living. Unit was renovated in 2019. Washer/dryer new in 2024. Unit was just freshly painted. Easily fits a king sized bed and ample seating/living area. Come and get your slice of Rye while it lasts! *photo with furniture is virtually staged Parking $60/mo. Assessement $60/mo through 4/30/2031. Minimum income $75k-$100k. Max DTI36%, max household debt 28%; minimum down payment 15%; minimum credit score 700 ****OWNER WILL COVER FULL ASSESSEMNT THROUGH 4/30/2031*****

24 Wappanocca Avenue Unit #J, Rye
$1,650,000
1010775 MLS
Attention Investors, Developers & Those Who Want to Build Their Dream Home in One of Westchester's Most Coveted Areas! IMAGINE: A blank canvas to build your dream home in the prestigious enclave of Rockledge Road. Private, yet convenient to downtown Rye and nearby White Plains. Fans of Apple TV's FRIENDS and NEIGHBORS might recognize this exclusive, tree lined street! Easy access to major highways and Metro North Rye train station. Close to highly acclaimed Rye Country Day School and world renowned Westchester Country Club. Take control of your lifestyle! Be creative, add beauty and live life on your own terms! Make your appointment today!

15 Rockledge Road, Rye
$1,795,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1008360 MLS
NEW 4 bedroom 4.5 bath townhome in the city of Rye close to all. This home features over 2,800 sq feet of living space with an open floor plan, The main level has a beautiful kitchen with large center island, stainless steel appliances, quartz countertop and backsplash, living room with fireplace, powder room, and sliding glass doors to a private deck overlooking the back yard. The second floor has a magnificent primary bedroom with a full bath, and spacious closets, 2 additional bedrooms, a hall bath, and washer/dryer. The 3rd level has a 4th bedroom, family room and a full bath, it can also be utilized as a private office, guest suite, or additional play area. The lower level is a large finished recreational room, with a gym, a full bath, natural light, and high ceilings.

86 B Maple Avenue, Rye
$1,795,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1008358 MLS
NEW 4 bedroom 4.5 bath townhome in the city of Rye close to all. This home features over 2,800 sq feet of living space with an open floor plan, The main level has a beautiful kitchen with large center island, stainless steel appliances, quartz countertop and backsplash, living room with fireplace, powder room, and sliding glass doors to a private deck overlooking the back yard. The second floor has a magnificent primary bedroom with a full bath, and spacious closets, 2 additional bedrooms, a hall bath, and washer/dryer. The 3rd level has a 4th bedroom, family room and a full bath, it can also be utilized as a private office, guest suite, or additional play area. The lower level is a large finished recreational room, with a gym, a full bath, natural light, and high ceilings.

86 A Maple Avenue, Rye
$1,525,000
1008303 MLS
Beautiful, elegant, community fully developed, Well established homes and landscaping throughout the entire community. A dream spot to build your once in a life time home. Close to town and parkways .

20 Mt. Holly, Rye
$4,480,000
6 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ 1004420 MLS
A rare convergence of privacy, scale, and effortless sophistication, this commanding Contemporary Colonial stands behind its own gated entry on 1.47 manicured, fully fenced acres. Located 23 miles from midtown Manhattan and moments from the storied grounds of Westchester Country Club, this one-of-a kind home offers privacy and tranquility, just 1.5 miles from the Rye train station, boutiques and dining. Soaring 10-foot ceilings and a dramatic 21-foot double-height living room set an architectural tone of quiet grandeur from the moment you arrive. Six ensuite bedrooms, including a main-floor second primary suite with spa-inspired bath, offer privacy at every turn, ideal for multi-generational living or distinguished guests. A media room, fully renovated chef's kitchen, newly built recreation room and whole-house Sonos system complete an interior conceived for both grand entertaining and unhurried everyday living. Outside, a private resort campus completed in 2020 anchors the grounds: a heated saltwater pool and spa, professional outdoor kitchen, two designer cabanas, and a tranquil cascading waterfall create a sense of year-round escape. Below grade, a finished lower level unfolds as a world unto itself, complete with a home gym, custom bar and multiple entertaining areas. An oversized three-car garage and full-house generator round out an offering defined by both luxury and ease — with taxes that significantly undercut comparable estates.

23 Pheasant Drive, Rye
$1,539,500
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 988403 MLS
Lovely Coonial Homewalk to Beach & Park & Schools: Midland Elementary School & Rye High. Winter Water View on tree lined street. House is larger than appears in listing. Livingroom, Formal Diningroom, Den, Home Office/Playroom, 4 Bedrooms. Cute EIK. Hardwood Floors, Ceramic Tiles. Dry painted Large basement with new oil tank & door to garden. NO flooding & no flood insurance required. Lots of Flowering Trees. Two large car Garages.

15 Roosevelt Avenue, Rye
Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.